Adopting Ideas from Other Forums

Welcome to Another Admin Forum!

Welcome to Another Admin Forum! Join our community of forum creators today. Register for a free account and get tips, resources, and support to build and grow your forum. Let's create better forums together!

Shawn Gossman

Administrator
AAF Administrator
AAF Moderator
Joined
Jul 5, 2024
Messages
1,269
Reaction score
233
Do you "adopt" ideas from other forums?

I think we all do to a certain point. None of the admin forums around today invented Forum of the Month competitions but we all do them :D

I think most of us adopt ideas even without realizing it.
 
Forum of the month started with Admin Addict. They were the first to do it. In fact there was a whole category dedicated to it. While AA is no more Admin Talk is. That's were all of AA went when I combined the 2 sites when I owned them.
I beg to differ. We've actually done Forum of the Week back in the days on InvisionFree. Earliest I can remember is 2003.
 
Looking back at the old Admin Addict, I have it running on localhost to see the exact date, first Community of the Month was July 2007. While there may have been some done before they were not well known or on what were the main forum admin sites.

TAZ, Admin Addict and Admin Extra were the admin forums to be a member of back in the day. Those heights will never be reached again. As much as I love forums I realize the end of nearing. The old guard is getting smaller and new people are not coming in to replace them. Look at the admin forums like yours and Admin Junkie. Same people.

You know what you don't see on any admin forum?

Users signing up and asking how to do things. It's rare for a new person to join and ask how to create a style for "insert software name here". Not only that. How many users on your forum use other software besides xenforo? Sure I see the rare Jcink forum owner or phpbb owner. For the most parts it's all xenforo.

Instead, as admin forum owners, of shunning Reddit and sites like it we should embrace it. Add forums to support users that use Reddit and other places like it.

Back when Stack Exchange first started I had the most popular Visual Basic forum. This was in Visual Basics heyday. Stack Exchange had a Visual Basic section. My staff was worried we would lose traffic to them. I told them to sign up there and help out. When they post I told them to add a link back to their profile on our site. Traffic went through the roof. We went from getting 100-200 new threads to over 1000 a day. If a person posted in seconds the post fell off the first page.

Would that work today? I would say if done right you could bring in some active users.

In any case I'm ranting now. Take what I say with a grain of salt. I been through the good times with forums and I will be there to the end. Even then I will keep mine online for archival purposes to show what once was.
 
I feel like I remember phpBB doing Forum of the Month back when v2 was big. That was around 2000.
 
Most contests that are run on different forums are modelled and ran as an inspiration from one forum or the other. I don't think it is bad either.
 
You know what you don't see on any admin forum?

Users signing up and asking how to do things. It's rare for a new person to join and ask how to create a style for "insert software name here". Not only that. How many users on your forum use other software besides xenforo? Sure I see the rare Jcink forum owner or phpbb owner. For the most parts it's all xenforo.
Xenforo has the greatest diaspora of casual hobbyist forum owners. Jcink forum owners are probably posting their support on Jcink; phpBB owners are posting their support questions on phpBB, etc.

Xenforo users, on the other hand, are widespread. As long as folks like Shawn and Cedric and yourself keep posting and the flame lit, that's the most that we can do.

One of the existential questions I ask myself is how many new conversations can we actually have about forums? Like, after fifteen years of discussing forums, how much more can we talk about dark mode or tags or "that time when a user backstabbed you"? I also wonder how open legacy forum admins are to actual community management, which is ... hard, and takes work, and involves strategy. Or if we just want to pop open our gaming site and install a pretty theme.

Can’t argue there. They were indeed more serious forums, where we on InvisionFree were considered not so serious. Still, we had the same amount of users, activity and traffic. But more with a free roaming audience.
I'm always astounded at the "pockets" of people in each software or platform and how popular each platform was on their own.

I was involved with SMF and Google Groups and Yahoo Groups in their heyday, and they had millions of users. If you add other platforms like phoBB, myBB, InvisionFree, Jcink and others, the totality of the entire forum audience was astounding in their heyday.
 
Yahoo Groups, now those were fun! I also remember MSN Groups. That was like a social network before social networks!
 
Before them all there was usenet. Fun with a 2800 baud modem.
And before that BBS's and FindoNet.
First site I set up ran on a 1200bps modem. Didn't take long to realize I needed faster if I was going to do much FidoNet related and eventually upgraded to USR 14.4K HST, then two HST and one dual standard and then finally 3 V.Everything modems with the DS used on a private mail only line (thank you SysOp plan).

Screen Shot 2024-12-12 at 2.59.00 PM.png


The fun thing was, all that actually started in 1990 and took it down in 1995 when we moved away from Dallas. Went from a Vendex HeadStart 8088 running DESQview and one line to eventually a 486/33 running OS/2 with 3 inbound public lines and one private mail only line.
The younger more innocent days of fun.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom